Marine Drive, reimagined: The future of a historic precinct | Mumbai news

Reclaimed from the sea in the early 20th century, from its inception, Marine Drive was part of an objective to reimagine Mumbai, then Bombay. There were several deliberations over its original plan, and by the time the precinct came up, the proposed built area of 1,145 acres was reduced to 552 acres.

The Backbay Reclamation scheme, as it was called, was dogged with delays, scandals and allegations of corruption–finally taking shape in an avatar far different from what was originally proposed by town planner WR Davidge. Even so, the controversial reclamation gave the city one of its most notable identifiers.

Despite his many reservations about the final execution of Marine Drive, it led eminent architect Claude Batley to comment: “If you have any doubt of its worthwhileness, watch the happy throngs of promenaders, of all sorts and conditions, drinking in the sea air morning and evening; an asset that has never been put down as of any tangible value in the profit-and-loss account of the scheme.”

These throngs of “happy promenaders”, the people of Marine Drive, are at the heart of this precinct. Urban plans, after all, remain only infrastructure projects until people imbue these areas with their stories and histories.

ALSO READ- Modi gets a warm welcome in US, holds talks with Biden

Over time, the precinct has endured several transformations of its own. The uniform skyline has been altered with floor additions, a controversial walkway was added at Chowpatty in the 1950s, the lights on Queen’s necklace went from yellow, to white and back to yellow. But is the precinct encountered with a more far-reaching reimagination? If yes, what do we retain and what do we lose?

Interventions and what they threaten to erase

In May 2023, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) released a plan to “beautify” all the sea-facing Art Deco buildings along Marine Drive in a uniform colour, much to the chagrin of residents who had already spent their own funds to paint their respective buildings.

A few months later, in September, news emerged of the proposal to demolish the 70-year-old Taraporewala Aquarium due to structural instabilities. By the end of the year, the Savitribai Phule Women’s Hostel, a five-storeyed Art Deco building, was brought down for redevelopment. This hostel was built around 1950 for students of Mumbai University, and was a safe and comfortable living arrangement for young women coming into the city by themselves. It embodied the spirit of freedom and security Marine Drive has offered people.

As 2024 has come around, the ambitious Mumbai Coastal Road project was opened. Along the stretch from the Princess Street Flyover to Girgaon Chowpatty, the promenade remains permanently altered to create wider space to accommodate the project.

ALSO READ- EY employee death: Rahul Gandhi speaks with Anna’s parents, says ‘I promised…’

Transparent canopies have been placed in front of the gymkhanas (Islam, Hindu, Parsi and Catholic, which occupy consecutive plots of land), where the underground tunnels coming from and going towards the north emerge. These gymkhanas, once open playing grounds with vistas of the sea, suddenly find themselves boxed in, with the sea view lost behind the tall canopies.

Lamenting this design, author and Bombay history fellow at Gateway House, a foreign policy think tank, Sifra Lentin says: “One must keep in mind that a city is only as good as its history. Development must go hand-in-hand with aesthetics and heritage, and Mumbai is lucky to have so many heritage precincts.”

Lentin’s views on the canopy are echoed by several Marine Drive residents. For Rohan Parikh, a 45-year-old entrepreneur who grew up on Marine Drive, south Mumbai is an ageing precinct, and “it is not ageing well.” “The centre of gravity has definitely moved north. Thankfully, the art galleries and the NCPA [National Centre for Performing Arts] are still in south Bombay, so we have some cultural heft. And that’s literally it,” says Parikh.

The coastal road, which will eventually be connected to the Eastern Freeway with a 9.23-kilometre corridor, will reintegrate south Mumbai with the rest of the city, Parikh says. In fact, a 2023 Government Regulation (GR) now makes provisions for many such alterations, permitting the redevelopment of the Marine Drive precinct, with certain restrictions that require maintaining its uniform skyline. Another proposed project that has been in discourse for several years is the statue of Shivaji Maharaj in the Arabian Sea, one kilometre off the shore, overlooking Marine Drive.

In a deeply congested city with less than 2 sqm of per capita open space (for context, the World Health Organisation standard is 9 sqm/capita), Marine Drive remains one of the few bastions of a free, public and open space, making it all the more relevant in the 21st century. Changes along this precinct spell a more elemental change in the fabric of the city itself.

ALSO READ- ‘Every day was a nightmare’: Bengal man returns home from Russia-Ukraine war

The “public” character of Marine Drive

“I would argue the promenade of Marine Drive doesn’t belong only to the precinct of Marine Drive. It belongs to the city at large,” says architect and professor Rahul Mehrotra. “And as the city has densified, the use of Marine Drive has intensified,” he adds. “If not for Marine Drive, if not for that stretch of land, that stretch of sea, and that smell of salt in the air, I would have left the city long back,” says Mahithi Pillay, a resident of Powai who makes it a point to visit Marine Drive every month, if not every fortnight. On the weekends, it is as if the “city’s guts spill out,” observes Lentin, as people throng the promenade.

What is the great allure of this strip of concrete by the sea? New York-based Project for Public Spaces presents criteria for what makes a successful public space. Some of these include comfort in people’s body language, accessibility to all people at all times, showing public displays of affection, habitual or familiar use, and the ability to improvise uses for the space.

Marine Drive checks off many of these boxes. It offers a “neutrality”, argues Mehrotra, which isn’t defined by any adjacent built form, nor by any “clues that suggest how it can be appropriated.” For the most part, its use is walking or jogging, and sitting along the seawall–activities that are not specific to any particular groups of people.

For architect and urbanist Neera Adarkar, this neutrality is also a product of the promenade’s linear dimension, which gives it what she calls its “no nonsense” quality. It is not a garden or congregation space where people can gather, thus limiting the nature of activities. This linearity is also what lends a degree of anonymity to people using the promenade, enabling a broad demographic to enjoy it. “Nobody is looking at you, because it is linear. You are either looking at the sea, or at the world behind you,” remarks Adarkar. A wider promenade or garden may introduce other activities, which in turn introduces hierarchies.

At any time of day, Marine Drive remains accessible and offers its patrons a degree of safety, by virtue of its openness. “I go at 5:30 in the morning for a walk, and I am alone, and it’s perfectly safe,” says Shobha Nayar, a 70-year-old resident of Marine Drive. For Jenai Wadia, a designer who has been renting her Marine Drive apartment since 2019, the precinct is a “safe and open space” to raise her children. “My sister’s in a wheelchair, and in most parts of Bombay it’s impossible with a wheelchair or a pram. But it’s been very easy to access the Marine Drive promenade,” Wadia says.

Then there is the temporal notion of the space, where with each passing hour its use evolves. The promenaders arrive in the morning and evening, when the severity of the sun is low. It is the afternoons, however, that are the most interesting, when young couples brave the intensity of the midday heat to, ironically, enjoy a degree of privacy in a public space. Marine Drive enables them to hold hands and exchange physical touch without fear of being watched or reprimanded–a rarity in India. It is what makes the promenade dynamic, with its ever-changing use over time, offering different kinds of experiences to different people.

“If you can plan a space in a way that you consider what it could do at different times, you make it more neutral. When we make a space too specific, then the associations with what happens there narrows,” says Mehrotra.

On 4 July 2024, as hordes of people trickled onto Marine Drive for the “victory parade” to celebrate India’s T20 Cricket World Cup win, the ability to improvise in a public space became all the more potent. Of all the options available in the city to host a massive congregation of people, like the DY Patil Stadium in Nerul or Shivaji Park, Marine Drive was the chosen venue, despite its narrow linearity.

A stadium or a ground could be located anywhere, but the promenade and the sea serve as immediate identifiers of Bombay. The stunning footage of the parade was telecast around the world, with the Art Deco apartment buildings to one side, the magnificent Arabian Sea to another–this will remain an enduring image of the city, and Marine Drive is at the heart of it.

Marine Drive and the right to the city

Bombay has famously enjoyed a history of engaged citizenship. The urban landscape of the city, as it developed in the 20th century, was built through the “joint enterprise” posits historian Preeti Chopra, between the colonial government, Indian and European mercantile elites, engineers, architects and artists. The historical continuity with this period has defined citizens’ actions in the city since, be it the making of the Bandra Bandstand promenade in the early 2000s, or the 14-year-long negotiation by citizens groups to bring UNESCO World Heritage Site status to the ‘Victorian Gothic and Art Deco Ensembles of Mumbai’ in 2018. It is this inscription that probably nudged the coastal road to start northward beyond the Princess Street flyover, saving the core precinct as a result.

The neutrality of the promenade, as Mehrotra articulates, is in the void of the bay. It is not organised around a monument or an object, but is instead a “reminder of our continuous engagement with the flux of nature, which is the tides of the sea.” Placing a statue that disrupts this void would significantly change the meaning of Marine Drive and its use.

Urban spaces like these become all the more relevant, as much of its character and use is defined by people. While Marine Drive’s design is inherently dynamic, its exuberance comes alive with how people interact with the space. With several simultaneous infrastructural projects being undertaken in the city, it is undeniable that Mumbai is in the throes of a rapid transformation. The people, for whom these new projects have been commissioned, however, frequently remain absent from the narrative, at a cost that remains to be seen.

But it is when people claim their “right to the city”, to use Henri Lefebvre’s frequently cited theory, that urban centres become more vibrant and inclusive, presenting opportunities to a broad demographic of people to lead a life of dignity in the metropolis. Marine Drive’s accessibility is “indicative of a countercultural contestation to reject any monopoly over sea views,” writes political scientist R. Swaminathan.

The urban planning of the precinct, despite early setbacks, presented the city’s residents with a way of life that holds value to date, and perhaps carries principles of design that can still serve as prototypes for larger residential planning in the city. In any reimagination of Mumbai, therefore, Marine Drive remains significant; and in any reimagination of Marine Drive, one must not lose sight of its people.